Welcome to quest notes, the place to go for news and information about all things related to the epic story. It was actually the name of the whole defensive system including its major defensive structure, the hornburg. The film is the second instalment in the lord of the rings trilogy and was produced by barrie m. In tolkiens account, there were no elves at helms deep aside from. Dec 07, 2015 haldir and the elf army at helms deep. This was a relic of the script treatment for miramax, which condensed the one thousand plus page novel into two movies, and met with fan fury on the internet with its freeandeasy approach to j. Helm s deep was one of my favorite scenes in the movie, but im currently rereading through the lord of the rings, and i forgot how different it was in the book. Osborne, fran walsh and jackson, and written by walsh, philippa boyens, stephen sinclair and jackson. The battle of helm s deep, also called the battle of the hornburg, is a fictional battle in j.
The climax of the entire documentary, as it was of the film, is helms deep. The two towers, book 3 of 6, chapter 7, and it is depicted in the. Since there was 3 lines of elves lining the entire deeping wall and about 100 elves in a line i would guess about 750 elves total in helms deep. Helms deep was one of my favorite scenes in the movie, but im currently rereading through the lord of the rings, and i forgot how different it was in the book. Tolkien legolas and gimli at helms deep by john howe attack of helms deep by cavini helms deep by darrell sweet the battle of the hornburg by ian miller the battle of helms deep by john howe the battle of helms deep by alan lee helms deep by agnus. And in the lotr book legolas is kinda dumb and gimli is smarter but in. Lorien however didnt actually send anything in the books.
Tolkien s the lord of the rings, that saw the total destruction of the forces of the wizard saruman by the army of rohan, assisted by a forest of treelike huorns. I am haldir, senior warden of the golden wood of lothlorien, captain of the galadhrim, defender of the race of men and of middleearth, and great elffriend to elessar telcontar. The lord of the rings film trilogy 20012003 is a cinematic adaptation of what is probably the greatest fantasy novel ever written. Jun 09, 2019 helm s deep was a large valley gorge in the northwestern ered nimrais white mountains below the thrihyrne. Why was the breaking of the wall of helms deep so important. The defenders of helms deep are the characters we see in the two towers and lets say they have the requisite arrows tipped with dragon glass and dragon glass swords. Some elves will appear in the battle of the pellenor fields.
Helm s deep was the largest fortress of rohan, where the guards of the fords of isen lived. Take a look at how some artists saw this part in the book. In tolkiens account, there were no elves at helms deep aside from legolas, and the elves of lorien were occupied in battles against forces out of moria and dol guldur, which were only mentioned in passing. The gorge narrowed from the north, with the cliffs on each side heightening until its southernmost point. This really showed the strength of men, and i really enjoyed it. When he hears the sound of boromirs horn and the cries of the orcs, aragorn runs to help boromir, calling the name elendil. Geography and descriptiothe valley was blocked over its entire width by a trench and rampart called helms dike and behind that lay the great fortress hornburg.
The lord of the rings, the fellowship of the ring, book two, chapter vi. Aragorn, legolas, and haldirs elves station on the deeping wall. Osborne, fran walsh and jackson, and written by walsh, philippa boyens. Elrond could request lorien elves to march to helms. Tolkien hobbittolkien bookslegolasthranduilthe hobbit characterscraig parkerhelms deeplotr elvesgreat warriors. The texan ben johnson from she wore a yellow ribbon with john wayne. Hundreds of hours of work really paid off with this epic battle. Originally, arwen liv tyler was to be included in the fighting force of elves who join the men, in the battle of helms deep.
I would like to believe that was the motive behind sending elves to helms deep. Dec 14, 2019 peter jacksons reasoning for adding the elves to the climactic helms deep battle is addressed on the commentary track for the lord of the rings. So i am glad to finally have a set in which to place the characters on my book readings of the battle. Lord of the rings battle of helms deep opening youtube. What you seem to be misunderstanding is the layout of helm s deep. Apr, 2003 well there was enough of them to man the deeping wall and there was also more elves on the ground behind the wall shooting arrows. The battle of helms deep film version council of elrond. How many elves did elrond send to the helms deep battle. Out of a grey country darkness lies and all paths are drowned deep in shadow haldir. In the book, as other answers have stated, the elves had their own problems and couldnt spare forces to help the rohirrim.
Wallpaper of helms deep for fans of lord of the rings 3067609. Tolkien and he authored the beloved epic tale long before the movies came into existence. Originally intended to be longer in length the battle of helm s deep will be in it s full form in the ee and will show the full faith of the elves. The battle for helms deep was supposed to signify that men were able to fight the horrors of the world on their own without the other races and it was a sign that they were fit to take charge after the elves left middle earth. The two towers, an army of elves arrives to support their human counterparts in the battle against saruman at helms deep, but things played out very differently in tolkiens original books. More importantly it takes away from one of the most important parts of rotk, namely eowyn facing down the witch king. Frodos trusty companion sam refuses to let frodo go it alone, so the two hobbits head to mordor together.
Also, its more than a bit silly that galadriel, who is the motherinlaw of elrond, would plead with him to send her own forces to helm s deep. The battle of helms deep was a cinematic marvel that helped establish peter jackson as a directing visionary, breaking ground in terms of the battles epic scale and mighty ambition. Where did the elves go after the helms deep battle in lotr. The battle of the hornburg, also popularly referred to as the battle of helms deep, took place at the mountain fortress of the hornburg in the valley of helms deep in rohan. It lay near the westfold, and was commonly known as the location of the hornburg. Helm s deep, named for helm hammerhand, was a fortified gorge in the white mountains located below the thrihyrne. Like all great works, critics have scrutinized the movies since the release of the first installment in 2001 and identified what appear to be, in addition to a litany of unresolved questions about the storyline, inconsistencies in the flow of the plot s logic. The wall, defended the actual helms deep the space we can see middle of the picture between the two rocks.
Check out these images of a custom lego lord of the rings helms deep that uses 150,000 bricks and 1700 minifigures. Jun 01, 2010 lord of the rings was the creation of j. It made for a cool movie scene, but why did haldir have to die user avatar. In the book did the elves go to helms deep in the lord of. The valley was lined over its entire width by the natural series of hills called helm s dike and behind that lay the fortress of aglarond or the hornburg, at the entrance to. Or maybe one of other blonde elves ed skrein, daario naharis. In the book did the elves go to helm s deep in the. Jackson rejected arwens involvement, revising her character from a warrior princess to a role closer to that of the book, but kept the elves in the battle. In this edition well be talking about the inclusion of the next three books of volume iii in the helms deep expansion, and some of the interesting challenges. Like all great works, critics have scrutinized the movies since the release of the first installment in 2001 and identified what appear to be, in addition to a litany of unresolved questions about the storyline, inconsistencies in the flow of the plots logic. Aragorn traces frodos path to amon hen and back again.
First read the books in 1968 and every four or five years since. In the hobbit book when bilbo and the dwarves get captured by the wood elves every thing is made of leaves and wood, but in the movie there is no clear difference between the high elves and the wood elves. Well there was enough of them to man the deeping wall and there was also more elves on the ground behind the wall shooting arrows. The two towers is a 2002 epic fantasy adventure film directed by peter jackson, based on the second volume of j. Not actually in the book, but a forgivable bit of artistic license. The battle of the hornburg, known in various adaptations as the battle of helm s deep, was the first grandscale battle of the war of the ring, where the rohirrim under king theoden defended the hornburg from sarumans army of men and urukhai. Each fully poseable action figure is outfitted with authentic weaponry and armor from the battle at helms deep. In the books, it isnt just rohan under assault from the titular two towers of orthanc and baraddur, but lothlorien and many other lands populated by the elvish and dwarf folk. The battle of the hornburg, known in various adaptations as the battle of helms deep, was the first grandscale battle of the war of the ring, where the rohirrim under king theoden defended the hornburg from sarumans army of men and urukhai. In the book of lost tales, tolkien includes both more serious medieval elves such as feanor and turgon alongside frivolous, jacobean elves such as the solosimpi and tinuviel. The white walker army consists of 100,000 wights, 12 white walkers, 3 giants plus one.
In one of the most memorable moments from the liveaction movie version of the lord of the rings. Helms deep was located in western rohan near isengard. Here is what i think is the most complex job of art direction in the piece, and perhaps the most difficult to understand. The finale of the two towers sees elves and men unite against the forces of saruman, but tolkiens original lord of the rings book was. Helms deep lord of the rings wallpaper 3067609 fanpop. In the books, legolas was the only elf at the battle of helms deep.
The battle of helms deep was a cinematic marvel that helped establish peter jackson as a directing. In the book, the elves from lothlorien were not involved in this battle. In the film, it is a climactic battle, the equivalent of the battle of the pelennor fields in the return of the king. They were repulsed by the power of the elves and galadriels ring. The battle of helms deep, also called the battle of the hornburg, is a fictional battle in j. The rohirrim, led by theoden, guarded the hornburg, while 200 elven archers under aragorn and haldir lined the battlement of the deeping wall. I didnt know this scene wasnt part of the book, but its my favorite in the lotr trilogy. I didnt know this scene wasnt part of the book, but it s my favorite in the lotr trilogy. It was later made famous by the battle of the hornburg, a major battle of the war of the ring. The galadhrim yeah, yeah, and this scene didnt happen in tolkien s manuscript either. This was taken from an interview with pj, i cant believe it, hes going out of.
The elves were at helms deep because lord elrond sent them, if you remember that in the two towers when arwen is leaving, lady galadriel appears sending thoughts to elrond and asks hi if he leaves men to stand alone, so he sent elves to fight in helms deep as the final help from him. In the books, the elves of lothlorien were dealing with issues of their own. A few days after the battle of helms deep, orcs from dol guldur swarmed into the forest of lothlorien in a fullscale assault. The two towers picks up right where we left the company at the end of the fellowship of the ring. Lord of the rings two towers heroes of helms deep action. But i loved the way jackson was so faithful in so many other ways that i forgave him. Plus, it was a cinematic ploy to give an excuse for the elves to participate in the battle of helms deep in the movie since they were never there in the book. Justified, given that hes sindarin, the second highest elf kindred in middleearth, between the noldor, the high or deep elves, but who tend more towards science and industry than the other tribes, and the nandor, the silvan or wood elves, who tend to be rather more rustic and unsophisticated but comprise the majority of the elves still. They made him out to be more of a fool than the main characters who were leading us through the movie. This is a picture of the betel of helms deep it is the biggest and most imported battel in the book but also in the book it is where the bond between elves end men is restored and it is the battel ware gandalf returns to the fellowship.
Haldir at helms deep helms deep, elf warrior, the hobbit. Where last we left off the company in the fellowship of the ring, frodo has finally decided to head to mordor on his own because the ring is working its dark magic on his buddies. This was taken from an interview with pj, i cant believe it, he s going out of. Although the halfelven brothers elladan and elrohir did turn up at dunharrow, this was after the battle of the hornburg had ended. Helms deep, named for helm hammerhand, was a fortified gorge in the white mountains located below the thrihyrne. Aragorn comes with a sword and knife, king theoden has a sword and helmet, gimli includes 4 axes and a helmet and legolas is equipped with a bow, quiver of arrows and a sword. Its kind of sad when there all slaughtered and that not one of them made it out alive. Not only were saurons forces working their way from mordor into gondor, but he also had a separade army based out of his old fortress of dol guldur in southern mirkwood.
Helms deep was one of the sequences tolkien was open to cutting out of the story in his comments on the zimmerman screen treatment, but the film makers made it one of the sequences they expanded upon the most. Did any elves survive the battle of helms deep answers. The galadhrim yeah, yeah, and this scene didnt happen in tolkiens manuscript either. Tolkiens the lord of the rings, that saw the total destruction of the forces of the wizard saruman by the army of rohan, assisted by a forest of treelike huorns. Why did the elves help at helms deep in the two towers movie. The wall, defended the actual helm s deep the space we can see middle of the picture between the two rocks. Helm s deep is a large valley in the northwestern ered nimrais white mountains below the thrihyrne located within the area of westfold in west rohan.
Because of this, they would need to play a bigger part in an already pretty expansive story or they would have to be quietly dropped from the plot. Battle of the hornburg the one wiki to rule them all fandom. Legolas was the only elf at that battle, and the only reinforcement troops to arrive were huorns and more rohirrim. During the battle of helms deep, lets replace the orcs with the white walkers and wights from the battle of winterfell game of thrones. Another week, another chapter of the lord of the rings reread. Haldir lorien the one wiki to rule them all fandom lotr wiki. Helms deep as portrayed in peter jacksons the lord of the rings. Their motivation for going to helms deep was completely different in the books.
They appear in the hobbit and in the lord of the rings, but their history is described more fully in the silmarillion tolkien derived his elves from mentions in the ancient poetry and languages of northern europe, especially old english. Battle of the hornburg the one wiki to rule them all. Why did jackson put elves in the battle of helms deep. To continue to the next time click the leaning banner helm s deep, sunrise sunrise occurs at the time of the quest vol. What you seem to be misunderstanding is the layout of helms deep. Helms deep was a large valley gorge in the northwestern ered nimrais white mountains below the thrihyrne.
Haldir lorien the one wiki to rule them all fandom. Haldir of lorien helms deep battle lotr elves, the hobbit. The elves and dwarves were fighting their own battles in the books. Haldir was an elf of lothlorien, probably a silvan elf, and a marchwarden who guarded the. Jun 22, 2015 theoden took every ablebodied man to helms deep. T 4 alongside the idea of the greater elves, tolkien toyed with the idea of children visiting valinor, the islandhomeland of the elves in their sleep. Jul 30, 2009 another week, another chapter of the lord of the rings reread. The elves at helms deep were a departure from the book version and were added for some reason by peter jackson and his team. The deeping wall protects the deep behind the keep, this is the only escape for the defenders. Originally intended to be longer in length the battle of helms deep will be in its full form in the ee and will show the full faith of the elves. Why did the elves help at helms deep in the two towers. The elves at helm s deep were a departure from the book version and were added for some reason by peter jackson and his team.
Tolkiens legendarium, elves are a fictional race inhabiting middleearth in the remote past. After being freed by gandalf from grima wormtongues influence, theoden went to the fords of isen where erkenbrand was battling sarumans orcs. Long ago an alliance existed between elves and men. Soon gandalf brought the rohirrim to defend these and helms deep from. Dec 28, 2019 the battle of the hornburg, also popularly referred to as the battle of helms deep, took place at the mountain fortress of the hornburg in the valley of helms deep in rohan. Their motivation for going to helm s deep was completely different in the books.
1308 707 352 449 1049 1417 365 39 172 1156 265 1068 1095 1271 1556 1231 1306 986 280 1198 689 300 723 985 832 376 1362 273 1145 1273